Pretend You're Gay

86 Newman's song "Pretend You're Gay" offers a satirical yet insightful commentary on toxic masculinity and the aggressive behaviors often associated with it. The lyrics describe a scenario where young men, driven by a need to assert their toughness, engage in confrontations and fights. This behavior is depicted as a misguided attempt to prove their masculinity, often through superficial means like their cars or physical altercations. The song's protagonist offers a unique solution to these aggressive encounters: pretending to be gay.

The chorus, "Pretend you're gay, works so well, pretend you're gay, what the hell," suggests that adopting a non-threatening, non-confrontational stance can effectively defuse potentially violent situations. By blowing a kiss or winking an eye, the protagonist subverts the expectations of the aggressors, who are so entrenched in their own notions of masculinity that they are frightened and confused by this unexpected response. This reaction exposes the fragility of their tough exterior and highlights the absurdity of their behavior.

86 Newman uses humor and irony to critique the societal norms that equate masculinity with aggression and dominance. The song encourages listeners to question these norms and consider alternative ways of handling conflict. By pretending to be gay, the protagonist not only avoids violence but also challenges the aggressors to rethink their own attitudes and behaviors. This clever and humorous approach underscores the importance of empathy, understanding, and the rejection of harmful stereotypes in fostering a more inclusive and peaceful society.