Pleader

Alt-J's song 'Pleader' is a poetic and evocative piece that delves into themes of nostalgia, nature, and the passage of time. The lyrics repeatedly ask, 'How green, how green was my valley?' This question serves as a refrain that underscores the song's central theme: a longing for a past that was lush, vibrant, and full of life. The valley symbolizes a place of beauty and tranquility, a stark contrast to the present, which may feel less idyllic.

The song's imagery is rich and vivid, painting a picture of a landscape that is both physically and emotionally significant. Phrases like 'to be held in such spots' and 'to behold such warmth' suggest a deep connection to the land, one that is both personal and communal. The mention of 'wild roses' and 'nightingales' further enhances this connection to nature, evoking a sense of harmony and peace. The use of the word 'agony' in 'happy agony we sing' introduces a bittersweet element, acknowledging that the beauty of the past is tinged with a sense of loss.

Cultural references also play a role in the song. The name 'Bronwen' and the exclamation 'Victoria! Victoria!' hint at a historical and possibly British context, adding layers of meaning to the lyrics. The song's structure, with its repeated refrains and choral elements, gives it a hymn-like quality, reinforcing the idea of a collective memory and shared experience. Alt-J's unique musical style, characterized by intricate arrangements and haunting melodies, complements the lyrical content, creating a piece that is both emotionally resonant and intellectually stimulating.