Ni Zai, Bu Zai

Amber Kuo's song 'Ni Zai, Bu Zai' (You Are, You Are Not) delves into the emotional turmoil of longing and the haunting presence of a loved one who is no longer physically present. The lyrics paint a vivid picture of the protagonist's struggle with the absence of someone significant, capturing the essence of heartache and the lingering memories that refuse to fade away.

The song opens with imagery of clouds turning into rain, symbolizing the protagonist's tears and sorrow as they wait for an apology that never comes. The mention of 'starlight like tears' and 'unspoken thoughts turning into black smoke' further emphasizes the depth of their longing and the transformation of their emotions into something dark and consuming. The recurring theme of waiting and the futility of expecting closure is palpable throughout the song.

Amber Kuo uses various metaphors to illustrate the omnipresence of the absent loved one. The lines 'You are in the room, like a phantom light' and 'You are in my eyes, filling them with tears' convey how the memories of the person continue to haunt the protagonist's daily life. The presence is so strong that it feels almost tangible, yet it is just an illusion, a figment of the past that cannot be grasped. The song also touches on the physical and emotional exhaustion that comes with this unending longing, comparing it to a month-long cold and a constant state of fatigue.

The chorus highlights the paradox of the loved one's presence and absence. The protagonist feels their presence in various forms—through memories, objects, and even in their heart—but they are painfully aware that the person is no longer by their side. This duality creates a sense of unresolved grief and a struggle to move on. The song's melancholic tone and poignant lyrics resonate with anyone who has experienced the pain of losing someone dear, making 'Ni Zai, Bu Zai' a powerful exploration of love, loss, and the enduring impact of memories.