You Didn't Know (feat. Erika Henningsen, Jessica Vosk, Patina Miller, Sam Haft, Shoba Narayan & Stephanie Beatriz)

The song "You Didn't Know" from Andrew Underberg, featuring Erika Henningsen, Jessica Vosk, Patina Miller, Sam Haft, Shoba Narayan, and Stephanie Beatriz, delves into a complex narrative about morality, redemption, and the afterlife. The lyrics present a heated debate among characters who are grappling with the concept of whether a soul deserves a second chance after death. The characters Emily and Charlie argue in favor of the possibility of improvement and redemption, even for those who have passed away, suggesting that change and growth should be recognized and rewarded with a second chance.

However, the character Sera presents a counterpoint, indicating that matters of the soul and afterlife are not as straightforward as they might seem. The song introduces a darker aspect when characters Adam and Lute dismiss the idea of redemption, emphasizing the permanence of hell and the finality of a person's actions on Earth. This introduces the theme of retribution over rehabilitation, with Adam even looking forward to the extermination of the damned souls.

The song reaches a climax when it is revealed that the characters were unaware of a crucial piece of information - that angels, like Sera, are involved in the extermination of souls in hell. This revelation leads to a sense of betrayal and the questioning of the moral high ground that angels are assumed to hold. The lyrics challenge the listener to consider the shades of gray in moral decisions and the hypocrisy that can exist within systems of belief that claim to be virtuous.