Middle / The River That Runs Both Ways

Aoife O'Donovan's song "Middle / The River That Runs Both Ways" is a poetic exploration of love, compromise, and the search for balance in a relationship. The lyrics paint a vivid picture of a couple navigating their differences and finding common ground. The imagery of a cabin, rain, and the Hudson River sets a serene yet introspective backdrop, emphasizing the intimate and personal nature of their journey.

The song begins with the couple in a cabin, a metaphor for their relationship. The thunder and rain symbolize external challenges and internal conflicts. Despite these, they find solace in each other's company, as indicated by the act of shutting the skylight to sleep. The mention of political art versus playing the old-time fiddle highlights their differing interests and values. Yet, the recurring plea to meet in the middle suggests a willingness to bridge these gaps and find harmony.

As the song progresses, the theme of compromise becomes more pronounced. The protagonist expresses a desire to get lost in the beauty of their relationship and even start a band together, symbolizing a shared future. The old-time fiddle, a recurring motif, represents a simpler, more genuine connection that transcends their differences. The reference to Henry Hudson and the clear sky over the Hudson River further underscores the idea of clarity and understanding in their relationship.

Ultimately, the song is a heartfelt reflection on the importance of meeting halfway in love. It acknowledges the challenges and differences but celebrates the beauty of finding common ground. The repeated refrain of staying in love "in the middle" encapsulates the essence of the song—a journey towards mutual understanding and harmony.