Not That Deep

Beth McCarthy's song "Not That Deep" delves into the complexities and uncertainties of romantic relationships. The lyrics explore the ambiguity and mixed emotions that often accompany love. The song opens with a scene of a couple in a living room, hinting at a moment of tension and potential separation. McCarthy questions how they reached this point and whether words alone could resolve their issues. This sets the stage for a deeper exploration of the relationship's nature and the doubts that cloud it.

The chorus reflects a series of 'maybes,' capturing the indecisiveness and confusion that can plague a relationship. McCarthy wonders if they are soulmates or simply on the same page, if they are too late to fix things, or if their connection is just a fleeting mistake. This repetition of 'maybe' underscores the uncertainty and the struggle to define the relationship. The metaphor of 'two left feet' suggests awkwardness and a lack of harmony, further emphasizing the difficulties they face.

As the song progresses, McCarthy contemplates whether to continue running from their problems or to confront them head-on. The imagery of clouds in the hallway and the desire to feel rain and thunder before morning symbolizes the emotional turmoil and the need for clarity. The bridge questions whether their connection is a mere flicker or something more profound, highlighting the overthinking and self-doubt that can sabotage a relationship. Ultimately, the refrain 'maybe it's just not that deep' serves as a coping mechanism, a way to downplay the significance of their struggles and perhaps find solace in simplicity.