He's a Demon, He's a Devil, He's a Doll
Betty Hutton
The Irresistible Charm of a Flawed Lover
Betty Hutton's song "He's a Demon, He's a Devil, He's a Doll" captures the tumultuous emotions of a woman entangled in a love-hate relationship. The lyrics paint a vivid picture of a man who is both charming and deceitful, a combination that leaves the protagonist in a constant state of emotional turmoil. Despite recognizing his flaws and the pain he causes, she finds herself unable to break free from his spell. This dichotomy is encapsulated in the repeated refrain, where she labels him a demon, a devil, and a doll, highlighting the complexity of her feelings.
The song delves into the internal conflict experienced by the protagonist. She acknowledges the advice of others and her own awareness of his shortcomings, yet she is repeatedly drawn back to him by his irresistible charm. This is evident in lines like "I would forget him if I only could" and "I forget why I'm mad." The lyrics also touch on the protagonist's self-awareness and frustration with her own inability to resist him, as seen in the humorous line, "My momma must have dropped me on my head."
Culturally, the song reflects the era's gender dynamics and the societal expectations placed on women in relationships. The protagonist's struggle to assert herself and break free from a toxic relationship mirrors the broader challenges faced by women in asserting their independence and agency. Betty Hutton's lively and expressive performance adds a layer of irony and humor to the song, making it both a poignant and entertaining exploration of love's complexities.