Por Ella

Carlos Gardel's song "Por Ella" is a poignant narrative set in the underworld of Buenos Aires, where love, pride, and violence intertwine. The lyrics tell the story of a beautiful and courageous woman who becomes the object of desire for two men. Her beauty and haughtiness make her a coveted prize among the local toughs, leading to a fierce rivalry between two malevos (tough guys) who both seek her affection. The woman, cunning and manipulative, promises to choose the one who can prove his manliness the most, setting the stage for inevitable conflict.

The climax of the song occurs when the two rivals confront each other in a deadly duel, witnessed by the woman. The tragic twist is that the man she truly loves is the one who falls dead at her feet. This moment of realization and loss is a powerful commentary on the futility of violence and the tragic consequences of pride and manipulation. The surviving malevo, filled with deep sorrow and regret, faces a long punishment for his actions. Before he is taken away, he marks the woman with a scar on her face, a permanent reminder of her betrayal and the cost of her coquettish behavior.

Gardel's "Por Ella" is a vivid portrayal of the harsh realities of life in the arrabal (slum) and the intense emotions that drive human behavior. The song's narrative structure and dramatic elements are characteristic of tango music, which often explores themes of love, betrayal, and loss. Gardel, a legendary figure in the world of tango, uses his powerful voice and emotive delivery to bring this tragic story to life, making it a timeless piece that resonates with listeners even today.