If She Would Have Been Faithful...

Chicago's song "If She Would Have Been Faithful..." delves into the bittersweet realization that sometimes, what seems like a devastating loss can lead to unexpected and profound happiness. The lyrics reflect on a past relationship where the protagonist was betrayed by a lover who had another affair. Initially, this betrayal was a source of pain and confusion, but with time and reflection, the protagonist comes to see it as a blessing in disguise.

The song's narrative is built around the idea of reconstructing the past through old photographs and memories, which no longer haunt the protagonist. Instead, these memories serve as a reminder of how far they've come. The betrayal, once a source of heartache, is now seen as a necessary step towards finding true love. The protagonist acknowledges that if the former lover had been faithful, they would have missed out on the genuine love they now experience with their current partner.

This theme of ironic gratitude is central to the song. The protagonist watches their current partner sleep, feeling a deep sense of contentment and belonging. The lyrics highlight the paradox of having to lose something to gain something even more valuable. This contradiction defies logical explanation but is a common experience in the journey of love and relationships. The song ultimately celebrates the unexpected paths that lead to true happiness and the importance of embracing life's twists and turns.