What Am I Supposed to Believe

Christopher Cross's song "What Am I Supposed to Believe" delves into the emotional turmoil and confusion that often accompany romantic relationships. The lyrics paint a vivid picture of a person grappling with the aftermath of a breakup, oscillating between hope and despair. The opening lines, "Some like it hot, Some like it cold, I like it best when it's untold," suggest a preference for the unspoken and the mysterious, perhaps indicating a reluctance to face harsh truths directly. This sets the stage for the emotional journey that follows.

The chorus, "What am I supposed to believe, Is it that you really love me," encapsulates the core of the song's theme: the struggle to discern genuine love from fleeting emotions. The protagonist is left questioning the sincerity of their partner's feelings, a common dilemma in relationships that have ended abruptly or without clear closure. The lines, "You took my heart and threw it away, You left me out in the rain," evoke a sense of betrayal and abandonment, intensifying the emotional weight of the song.

As the song progresses, the lyrics shift towards a plea for reconciliation and the longing for a return to happier times. The lines, "Won't you come home to me, You could make everything all right," express a deep yearning for the comfort and warmth that the relationship once provided. This longing is juxtaposed with the harsh reality of living alone, highlighting the difficulty of moving on after experiencing a profound connection. Christopher Cross's soft rock style, characterized by smooth melodies and heartfelt lyrics, amplifies the emotional resonance of the song, making it a poignant exploration of love, loss, and the quest for understanding.