What If

Colbie Caillat's song 'What If' delves into the hopeful and dreamy musings of someone who is deeply infatuated and wonders about the potential of a true, lasting love. The lyrics capture the essence of romantic daydreams, where the protagonist imagines a future filled with love, companionship, and shared moments. The song's narrative is built around the 'what if' scenarios that many people entertain when they meet someone who makes their heart race.

The song opens with the protagonist observing their love interest from a distance, feeling a mix of hope and uncertainty. The lyrics, 'I pretend you notice me / I look in your eyes and what ya see,' reflect the internal dialogue of someone who is unsure if their feelings are reciprocated. This uncertainty is a common theme in romantic songs, where the fear of unrequited love is juxtaposed with the hope of mutual affection.

As the song progresses, the protagonist's imagination runs wild with possibilities. The lines 'What if we were made for each other / Born to become best friends and lovers' encapsulate the idealistic view of love as a predestined, perfect match. This notion is further emphasized with the imagery of writing names in the sand and envisioning a marriage proposal. The recurring question, 'Is it made up in my mind? / Am I crazy just wasting time?' highlights the internal conflict between hope and doubt.

The song's chorus, with its repetitive and emphatic 'What if this could be a real love,' underscores the protagonist's longing for a genuine connection. The emotional climax is reached with the realization that the love interest makes the protagonist's 'heart stop,' a metaphor for the overwhelming feelings of love and excitement. Colbie Caillat's soothing voice and the song's gentle melody enhance the dreamy, introspective quality of the lyrics, making 'What If' a relatable anthem for anyone who has ever wondered about the possibilities of love.