What If

Creed's song 'What If' delves into the emotional turmoil and moral questioning that arises from experiencing betrayal and deceit. The lyrics express a struggle to find meaning and maintain a sense of time and purpose when faced with the dishonesty of others. The mention of 'the words of men who have no grounds' suggests a feeling of being wronged by those who speak and act without justification, leading to a sense of being beaten down.

The chorus poses a series of rhetorical questions, 'What if you did? What if you lied? What if I avenge? What if eye for an eye?' These lines reflect the internal conflict between the desire for revenge and the consequences of such actions. The concept of 'an eye for an eye' is an ancient principle of retributive justice, but the song questions the validity and outcome of this approach. The repetition of 'What if?' throughout the song emphasizes the uncertainty and contemplation of taking action against those who have caused harm.

The latter part of the song acknowledges the destructive power of hate and the importance of controlling one's thoughts to avoid being consumed by them. The artist recognizes that harboring hate can control one's life, and instead of acting on these negative emotions, they choose to ask 'What if?' This refrain suggests a search for alternative responses to injustice, highlighting the importance of questioning one's instincts and the potential consequences of seeking vengeance.