Crush With Eyeliner

“Crush With Eyeliner” by Crematory delves into the complexities of infatuation and the lengths one might go to win the affection of someone seemingly unattainable. The song's protagonist is captivated by a woman who is described with vivid, almost surreal imagery, such as “a sad tomato” and “three miles of bad road.” These metaphors paint a picture of someone who is both intriguing and troubled, adding layers to her allure. The protagonist's fascination is palpable, as he describes himself as “smitten” and “the real thing,” emphasizing the depth of his feelings.

The lyrics explore the theme of self-invention and the pressure to present oneself in a certain way to gain the attention of the object of one's affection. Lines like “What position should I wear?” and “How can I convince her that I'm invented, too?” highlight the protagonist's internal struggle to appear worthy and interesting. This reflects a broader commentary on the performative aspects of attraction and the often superficial nature of romantic pursuits. The repeated references to “faker” and “fake her” underscore the tension between authenticity and the desire to be noticed.

Cultural references, such as “Frankenstein” and “valentine,” add a layer of irony and dark humor to the song. The protagonist's willingness to become a “Frankenstein” for his crush suggests a readiness to transform himself, even if it means losing his true identity. This speaks to the sometimes destructive nature of infatuation, where the line between genuine affection and obsession can blur. The song ultimately captures the bittersweet essence of unrequited love and the lengths to which one might go to bridge the gap between fantasy and reality.