Couldn't Tell

Dermot Kennedy's song "Couldn't Tell" is a poignant exploration of love, longing, and the complexities of human emotions. The lyrics paint a vivid picture of a relationship that is both deeply cherished and fraught with uncertainty. The opening lines, "They question the king upon leaving / Said: open your eyes when you see," suggest a moment of introspection and realization. The reference to the king could symbolize a person of great importance or authority, perhaps the singer himself, who is being advised to be more aware and perceptive.

The recurring theme of birds and their singing is a powerful metaphor for joy and freedom. The line, "I've started to see the birds need a reason to sing," implies that happiness and contentment are not automatic; they require a reason or a catalyst. This could be a reflection of the singer's own emotional state, where the presence of his loved one brings him joy and purpose. The imagery of dancing under circular ceilings and the sacred secrets being kept adds a layer of intimacy and mystique to the relationship.

The chorus, with its plea to bring back memories of past summers and the vulnerability expressed in lines like "All in, fall in / Vulnerable as hell," captures the essence of longing and the desire to relive cherished moments. The repeated phrase, "Now I couldn't tell / But she's keeping me well," suggests a sense of confusion and ambivalence, yet also a recognition that the relationship, despite its challenges, provides a sense of well-being and completeness. The song beautifully encapsulates the bittersweet nature of love, where moments of doubt and insecurity coexist with deep affection and connection.