Gentleman Soldier

The Dubliners' song "Gentleman Soldier" tells a poignant and somewhat tragic story of a brief romantic encounter between a soldier and a young woman named Polly. The narrative begins with the soldier standing guard and catching Polly's attention with a wave. Their interaction quickly escalates to a kiss and a night spent together in the sentry box, wrapped in the soldier's cloak. The drums and fifes, symbols of military life, serve as a constant reminder of the soldier's duty and transient nature.

As dawn breaks, the soldier prepares to leave, expressing a bittersweet farewell to Polly. Despite her plea for marriage, he reveals that he is already married with children, making it clear that their night together was nothing more than a fleeting moment. This revelation highlights the soldier's deception and the harsh reality of his commitments, leaving Polly to face the consequences alone.

The song delves into themes of love, betrayal, and societal expectations. Polly's predicament is further complicated by the social stigma of bearing a child out of wedlock. The soldier's advice to Polly, to present herself as a country lass and hide their encounter, underscores the gender dynamics and the limited options available to women in such situations. The final verse, where Polly gives birth to a child without knowing the father's name, encapsulates the lasting impact of their brief liaison and the emotional and social burden she must bear.

"Gentleman Soldier" is a powerful narrative that combines traditional folk storytelling with a critical look at the consequences of fleeting romances and the societal pressures faced by women. The Dubliners' rendition brings this story to life with their signature blend of heartfelt vocals and evocative instrumentation.