You Could Have Been With Me

Sheena Easton's song "You Could Have Been With Me" delves into the emotional turmoil of unfulfilled potential and missed opportunities in a relationship. The lyrics paint a picture of a person who is unique and special, described as the 'seventh son of the seventh son,' a phrase often associated with mystical or extraordinary qualities. However, despite these attributes, the individual struggles with self-love and, by extension, the ability to love others. This internal conflict creates a barrier that prevents the person from fully engaging in meaningful relationships.

The song uses vivid metaphors to illustrate the frustration of trying to help someone who is unwilling or unable to change. The line 'You can lead a horse to water, but you cannot make him drink' encapsulates the futility of offering support to someone who doesn't take it. Similarly, 'You can give a man your whole heart and soul, but you cannot make him think' highlights the emotional investment that goes unreciprocated. These metaphors underscore the singer's sense of helplessness and disappointment.

The recurring refrain, 'You could have been with me instead of alone and lonely,' serves as a poignant reminder of what could have been. It reflects the singer's sorrow and regret over the lost potential of the relationship. The lyrics question the reliability and commitment of the person, asking whether he is 'a man or a paper tiger,' and whether he will 'run or stand beside you' when needed. This uncertainty adds to the emotional weight of the song, making it a powerful exploration of love, loss, and the pain of unfulfilled potential.