What's The Matter With Me?

Ella Fitzgerald's song 'What's The Matter With Me?' delves into the emotional turmoil of unrequited love and the feelings of loneliness that accompany it. The lyrics express a deep sense of self-doubt and confusion as the protagonist questions why they are perpetually unlucky in love. The repeated refrain 'What's the matter with me?' highlights the internal struggle and the search for answers in the face of constant romantic disappointment.

The song uses vivid metaphors and cultural references to convey the protagonist's plight. The comparison to 'Punch and Judy,' a traditional puppet show known for its comedic yet violent interactions, suggests that the protagonist's love life is filled with conflict and drama. This metaphor underscores the chaotic and unfulfilling nature of their romantic experiences. Additionally, the mention of reading 'a million novels' with varying outcomes of love affairs reflects the protagonist's longing for a successful romance, contrasting sharply with their own reality of never having experienced a first kiss.

Ella Fitzgerald's soulful delivery and the melancholic tone of the song amplify the sense of isolation and yearning. The lyrics also touch on the protagonist's introspective nature, as they 'walk with myself, talk with myself,' indicating a deep internal dialogue and self-reflection. This introspection, however, only leads to more questions and a sense of mystery about their inability to find love. The song poignantly captures the universal experience of feeling unlovable and the heartache of unfulfilled romantic desires.