Criminal

Fiona Apple's song 'Criminal' is a raw and introspective look at guilt and the desire for redemption. The lyrics convey the emotions of someone who has wronged a person they care about and is grappling with the consequences of their actions. Apple uses the metaphor of being a 'criminal' to express the severity of her guilt and the moral judgment she places upon herself. The song's protagonist acknowledges their wrongdoing and expresses a strong desire to be punished and forgiven, highlighting a complex relationship with personal accountability and the need for absolution.

The song also touches on themes of love and self-worth. The line 'Because he's all I ever knew of love' suggests a deep connection to the person she has hurt, and possibly a fear of losing the only love she has known. This adds a layer of desperation to her plea for guidance and redemption. The internal struggle is evident as the protagonist seeks to reconcile their actions with their desire to be 'good enough' for their loved one. The repeated requests for a 'good defense' and the acknowledgment of the 'evil deeds' suggest a tension between the desire to escape judgment and the need to face the consequences.

Musically, 'Criminal' is delivered with Apple's signature style, which blends elements of alternative rock and jazz, creating a moody and intense atmosphere that complements the song's themes. The song's critical acclaim and enduring popularity reflect its powerful emotional resonance and the universal themes of guilt, redemption, and the complexities of human relationships.