Gay Boyfriend

Garfunkel and Oates' song "Gay Boyfriend" is a humorous yet poignant exploration of a unique romantic relationship. The lyrics tell the story of a woman who is deeply in love with her boyfriend, who she suspects is gay. Despite this, she cherishes the emotional connection and the affection he provides, which she finds unparalleled compared to her past relationships. The song delves into the complexities of love, identity, and the acceptance of unconventional relationships.

The protagonist describes her boyfriend as the perfect partner in many ways—he is attentive, communicative, and affectionate. He writes her love notes, takes her shopping, and even enjoys activities typically associated with female friendships, like slumber parties. This dynamic creates a sense of fulfillment for her, even though she acknowledges the likelihood of his homosexuality. The song cleverly juxtaposes traditional romantic expectations with the reality of their relationship, highlighting the emotional and physical intimacy they share despite the lack of sexual compatibility.

The lyrics also touch on the societal and personal challenges of coming out. The protagonist is aware that her boyfriend has not yet come out of the closet, and she is prepared for the eventual end of their relationship when he does. This awareness adds a layer of bittersweetness to the song, as she knows their fairytale will eventually conclude. However, she remains grateful for the love and companionship they share in the present. The song ultimately celebrates the idea that love and connection can transcend conventional boundaries, offering a fresh perspective on relationships and identity.