Confianzas
Gotan Project
The Powerlessness of Poetry: A Reflection on 'Confianzas' by Gotan Project
Gotan Project's song 'Confianzas' delves into the limitations and perceived powerlessness of poetry in effecting tangible change in the world. The lyrics, written in Spanish, present a stark and somewhat cynical view of the role of poetry in society. The repeated lines, 'con este poema no tomarás el poder' ('with this poem, you will not take power') and 'con estos versos no harás la Revolución' ('with these verses, you will not make the Revolution'), emphasize the futility of expecting poetry to bring about political or social upheaval.
The song goes on to list various practical needs and desires that poetry cannot fulfill. It won't help laborers, teachers, or woodcutters live or eat better, nor will it help the poet himself improve his own life. Poetry won't earn money, provide free cinema tickets, or procure clothing, tobacco, or wine. The lyrics even extend to more whimsical items like parrots, scarves, boats, bulls, and umbrellas, underscoring the idea that poetry is ineffectual in meeting both essential and trivial needs.
Despite this seemingly bleak perspective, the act of writing itself is portrayed as an inevitable and almost compulsive endeavor. The poet 'se sienta a la mesa y escribe' ('sits at the table and writes'), suggesting that the creation of poetry is an intrinsic part of the poet's existence, regardless of its practical utility. This duality highlights a deeper truth about art: while it may not directly change the world, it remains a vital expression of human experience and emotion.
Gotan Project, known for their fusion of tango and electronic music, often explores themes of cultural and social significance. 'Confianzas' fits within this framework, offering a contemplative look at the role of art in society. The song invites listeners to reflect on the intrinsic value of artistic expression, even when it doesn't lead to immediate, tangible outcomes.