Why We Ever

Hayley Williams' song "Why We Ever" delves into the emotional aftermath of a relationship that has ended, leaving the protagonist grappling with the reasons behind the separation. The lyrics open with a plea for warmth and connection, highlighting the protagonist's sense of alienation and longing. The imagery of standing on the 'stranger side' of a door suggests a barrier that has formed between the two individuals, both physically and emotionally.

The chorus reveals the protagonist's confusion and inability to recall why the relationship ended in the first place. This amnesia about the reasons for the breakup underscores the lingering feelings and unresolved emotions that continue to haunt them. The use of a 'tin-can telephone' metaphorically represents the outdated and ineffective means of communication, emphasizing the distance and disconnection that have grown over time.

As the song progresses, the protagonist's introspection deepens. They spend time alone, drawing circles on the floor, a repetitive and futile action that symbolizes their attempt to make sense of their pain. The repeated apologies for 'freaking out' indicate a desire for reconciliation and understanding, as well as a recognition of their own role in the relationship's demise. Ultimately, "Why We Ever" is a poignant exploration of the complexities of human connections, the pain of separation, and the yearning for closure and communication.