Peach, Plum, Pear

Joanna Newsom's 'Peach, Plum, Pear' is a hauntingly beautiful song that delves into themes of change, introspection, and the passage of time. The lyrics are rich with metaphors and vivid imagery, painting a picture of a relationship that has evolved and perhaps deteriorated over time. The song opens with a conversation in a store, where the narrator feels inadequate and surprised by the other person's demeanor. This sets the tone for a narrative filled with self-doubt and reflection.

As the song progresses, Newsom uses the metaphor of 'what was golden went gray' to signify the loss of something precious and the inevitable changes that come with time. The 'gathering floozies' and 'sneezing darkly' in the 'dimming divide' evoke a sense of decay and disillusionment. The narrator's attempt to interpret the other person's looks and the feeling of being 'knocked down with the palm of your eye' suggest a deep emotional impact and a struggle to understand the dynamics of the relationship.

The chorus, with its repetitive 'na na na' refrain, serves as a poignant interlude, emphasizing the emotional weight of the narrative. The lines 'This was unlike the story / It was written to be' reflect a sense of disillusionment and unmet expectations. The imagery of 'galloping manic' and 'swallowing panic' conveys a sense of urgency and fear in the face of change. The song concludes with a sense of resignation and acceptance, as the narrator acknowledges the changes in both themselves and the other person. The repeated mention of 'Peach, plum, pear' at the end serves as a nostalgic reminder of simpler, perhaps happier times.

Newsom's unique vocal style and intricate harp arrangements add layers of complexity to the song, making it a deeply emotional and introspective piece. The song's exploration of change, self-awareness, and the passage of time resonates with listeners, inviting them to reflect on their own experiences and relationships.