Story Of Isaac
Leonard Cohen
The Sacrificial Dilemma in Leonard Cohen's 'Story Of Isaac'
Leonard Cohen's 'Story Of Isaac' is a profound and haunting retelling of the biblical story of Abraham and Isaac, infused with modern-day reflections on authority, sacrifice, and morality. The song opens with a vivid scene where a young boy, Isaac, witnesses his father preparing to carry out a divine command. The imagery of the father standing tall with cold, shining blue eyes and a golden axe sets a tone of both reverence and dread. This duality captures the tension between faith and fear, obedience and resistance, that runs throughout the song.
As the narrative progresses, the journey up the mountain becomes a metaphor for the escalating gravity of the situation. The shrinking trees and the lake described as a lady's mirror evoke a sense of isolation and introspection. The breaking of the wine bottle symbolizes the shattering of innocence and the irreversible nature of the father's decision. The ambiguous sighting of an eagle or a vulture further underscores the uncertainty and the thin line between salvation and doom. The father's construction of an altar and his trembling hand highlight the human struggle with divine commands and the moral weight of such actions.
In the latter part of the song, Cohen shifts from the personal to the universal, addressing those who 'build these altars now to sacrifice these children.' This powerful critique extends beyond the biblical narrative to comment on contemporary issues of war, authority, and the misuse of power. The lines 'A scheme is not a vision' and 'You were not there before' challenge the legitimacy of those who justify violence and sacrifice without true understanding or experience. The closing verses, with their conditional offers of help or harm, reflect the complex interplay of duty, morality, and the human condition. The final image of the peacock spreading its fan serves as a poignant reminder of the vanity and futility that often accompany such grandiose displays of power and sacrifice.