What If

Mackenzie Ziegler's song 'What If' delves into the complexities of unspoken feelings and the uncertainties that come with them. The lyrics explore the tension between wanting to express one's emotions and the fear of the potential consequences. The opening lines, 'Let's talk about all the things that we shouldn't talk about,' set the stage for a conversation that is both risky and necessary. This sets up a narrative where the protagonist is grappling with whether to reveal their true feelings, knowing that doing so could change everything.

The recurring question, 'What if I told you I like you?' serves as the emotional core of the song. It encapsulates the vulnerability and the stakes involved in confessing one's feelings. The lyrics ponder various scenarios, such as the possibility of being together or the risk of losing it all. This internal debate is further complicated by external opinions, as mentioned in the lines, 'I hear everything they saying, saying 'bout us.' The song suggests that love is not about right or wrong but about what feels true to the individuals involved.

The repetition of the phrase 'What if' throughout the song emphasizes the uncertainty and the myriad possibilities that come with taking emotional risks. The lyrics also touch on the idea of missed opportunities, as seen in the line, 'What if I've been missing the writing on the wall?' This suggests a fear of overlooking signs and the regret that might follow. Ultimately, 'What If' is a poignant exploration of the courage it takes to confront one's feelings and the myriad outcomes that could result from such a brave act.