Should've Been Me

Mitski's song 'Should've Been Me' is a poignant reflection on missed opportunities and the pain of realizing that one has not met the emotional needs of someone they care about. The lyrics convey a sense of regret and self-awareness, as the narrator acknowledges their failure to be present for someone who desired their love and attention. The song opens with the narrator experiencing a 'clean feeling' and 'strange serenity,' which suggests a moment of clarity or a significant emotional breakthrough. However, this clarity is tinged with sadness as they recognize their shortcomings in a relationship.

The imagery of seeing a girl who looks just like the narrator and the emotional response it triggers indicates a moment of empathy and understanding. The narrator sees their own reflection in someone else and realizes the extent of their partner's efforts to connect with them. The repeated lines 'I haven't given you what you need' and 'I'm sorry it should've been me' serve as a haunting chorus that underscores the theme of regret. The song's narrative is further enriched by the metaphor of being dropped into a labyrinth, symbolizing the complexity and confusion that often accompany relationships.

Mitski is known for her emotionally charged lyrics and her ability to convey complex feelings through her music. 'Should've Been Me' is no exception, as it captures the melancholy of looking back on a relationship and wishing one had acted differently. The song resonates with anyone who has ever felt they let someone down or failed to be the person they were needed to be. It's a reminder of the importance of being present and attentive in our relationships and the pain that can result when we fall short of those expectations.