Porquê
Murta
The Unanswered Questions of Love: Analyzing Murta's 'Porquê'
Murta's song 'Porquê' delves into the emotional turmoil and confusion that follows a sudden and unexplained breakup. The lyrics are a poignant exploration of the feelings of abandonment and the desperate need for closure. The song opens with a reflection on the uncertainty of the future and the collapse of a once-stable world. This imagery sets the stage for the emotional journey that follows, where the protagonist grapples with the pain of a love that has ended without explanation.
The recurring question 'Porquê?' (Why?) underscores the protagonist's struggle to understand the reasons behind the breakup. The lyrics suggest a sense of betrayal and frustration, as the protagonist confronts their partner, seeking answers that are not forthcoming. The line 'Quem cala consente, é porque tás a esconder' (Silence means consent, it's because you're hiding) highlights the suspicion and mistrust that have taken root in the relationship. This silence from the partner only deepens the protagonist's sense of confusion and hurt.
Murta's use of metaphors, such as 'Água mole em pedra dura tanto bate até que fura' (Soft water on hard stone, it hits until it pierces), illustrates the persistent and wearing nature of seeking answers and the emotional toll it takes. The song's repetitive structure and the haunting refrain of 'Porquê?' emphasize the cyclical nature of these unanswered questions and the lingering pain of unresolved emotions. Through 'Porquê,' Murta captures the universal experience of seeking closure and the difficulty of moving on without understanding why a relationship ended.