Carnival

Natalie Merchant's song 'Carnival' is a reflective and introspective exploration of the human experience as seen through the metaphor of a bustling, chaotic street carnival. The lyrics paint vivid imagery of a world that is both dazzling and disorienting, filled with actors, thrill-seekers, vendors, and mystics. This carnival represents the myriad of experiences and people one encounters in life, each playing their part in the grand spectacle of existence.

The recurring question, 'Have I been blind?' suggests a deep self-examination and a sense of awakening. Merchant seems to be questioning her own awareness and perception, wondering if she has been too absorbed in the superficial aspects of life, hypnotized and mesmerized by the sights around her. This introspection is further emphasized by the contrast between wealth and poverty, the diamond market, and the scarlet welcome carpet, symbolizing the extremes and contradictions present in society.

The song also touches on themes of disillusionment and the search for meaning. The 'wild-eyed mystic prophet' who raves about saving her represents the various voices and influences that one encounters, each offering their own version of truth and salvation. Merchant's repeated questioning of whether she has been wise or wrong, strong or hypnotized, reflects the internal struggle to find clarity and authenticity amidst the noise and chaos of the world. 'Carnival' ultimately serves as a poignant reminder of the importance of self-awareness and the need to look beyond the surface to truly understand the essence of our experiences.