I Would

One Direction's 'I Would' is a poignant exploration of unrequited love and the longing for a romantic connection that seems just out of reach. The lyrics tell the story of someone who is deeply infatuated with a person who is already in a relationship with someone else. The protagonist of the song spends time fantasizing about being the significant other, imagining scenarios where they are the better choice, the one who would truly cherish and love the person they desire.

The song's chorus, with its repeated inquiries of 'Would he say he's in l-o-v-e? Well if it was me then I would, I would,' emphasizes the protagonist's belief that they could offer a deeper, more genuine love than the current boyfriend. This is further highlighted by the contrast between the protagonist's daydreams and the harsh reality of their situation, where they feel invisible and inadequate, symbolized by the line 'With a sign on my back saying ‘kick me’.' The mention of the boyfriend's '27 tattoos' serves as a metaphor for the boyfriend's apparent edginess or allure that the protagonist feels they cannot compete with.

The song resonates with anyone who has ever experienced the pain of loving someone from afar, especially when that love is overshadowed by the presence of another. It captures the essence of teenage angst and the complexities of young love, where emotions are intense and the fear of rejection is a constant companion. The lyrics are a mix of hope and despair, reflecting the inner turmoil that comes with unrequited feelings and the wishful thinking that maybe, just maybe, they would be the better choice if given the chance.