All Nighter

In 'All Nighter,' Overstreet delves into the emotional turmoil of a love that lingers long after the relationship has ended. The song captures the essence of sleepless nights filled with thoughts of a past lover, highlighting the difficulty of moving on. The repeated phrase 'I been lyin' awake just to keep a light on' symbolizes the protagonist's struggle to find solace and clarity in the darkness of their thoughts. This imagery of staying awake to keep a light on serves as a metaphor for the hope that the relationship might rekindle, even though the reality is quite the opposite.

The lyrics paint a vivid picture of the remnants of the past relationship that continue to haunt the protagonist. Items like a coat in the closet and a picture in the wallet serve as tangible reminders of what once was. The mention of 'fallin' back to you' juxtaposed with the ex-lover 'falling back to sleep with someone new' underscores the painful contrast between the protagonist's lingering feelings and the ex-lover's apparent ease in moving on. This dichotomy amplifies the sense of loneliness and unrequited love that permeates the song.

The recurring line 'Tryin tryin tryin but I can't kill the fire' encapsulates the protagonist's futile attempts to extinguish the burning emotions that refuse to fade. The 'fire' here is a powerful metaphor for the enduring passion and unresolved feelings that keep the protagonist awake at night. The song's title, 'All Nighter,' aptly reflects the endless nights spent grappling with these emotions. Overstreet's poignant lyrics and emotive delivery make 'All Nighter' a relatable anthem for anyone who has struggled to let go of a past love.