Who Said I Would

Phil Collins' song 'Who Said I Would' delves into the complexities of unrequited love and emotional struggle. The lyrics paint a vivid picture of a man who is deeply infatuated with a woman who seems emotionally distant and unresponsive. Despite his efforts to win her over, she remains indifferent, leading him to question his own worth and the nature of their relationship. The repeated refrain 'Who said I would' underscores his frustration and confusion, as he grapples with the reality that his feelings are not reciprocated in the way he desires.

The song's narrative is built around the metaphor of a 'heart made of stone,' which symbolizes the woman's emotional unavailability. This metaphor highlights the man's perception of her as cold and unfeeling, despite the physical attraction and moments of intimacy they share. The lyrics also touch on themes of dependency and self-worth, as the man acknowledges that he comes running every time she needs him, yet he is aware that she values him more for his physical presence than for any emotional connection. This dynamic creates a sense of imbalance and longing, as he yearns for a deeper, more meaningful relationship.

Phil Collins' musical style, characterized by its emotive vocals and powerful instrumentation, enhances the song's emotional impact. The solo section in the middle of the song adds a layer of intensity, reflecting the inner turmoil and passion of the protagonist. 'Who Said I Would' is a poignant exploration of the pain and confusion that often accompany unrequited love, capturing the essence of human vulnerability and the desire for genuine connection. The song resonates with listeners who have experienced similar emotional struggles, making it a timeless piece in Collins' repertoire.