Who's More Sorry Now?

In 'Who's More Sorry Now?' by Pixies, the lyrics delve into themes of regret, accountability, and the emotional aftermath of a relationship. The song opens with the protagonist cleaning out a closet, a metaphor for sorting through past memories and unresolved issues. The discovery of 'a pair of running shoes' and 'something overdue' suggests a history of avoidance and procrastination, hinting at unresolved conflicts or unfulfilled promises. The recurring question, 'Who's more sorry now?' underscores a sense of mutual regret and the difficulty in assigning blame or responsibility.

The mention of Henry David Thoreau, a philosopher known for his reflections on simple living and self-reliance, adds a layer of introspection. It suggests that the characters in the song are grappling with their own principles and the consequences of their actions. The line 'See how much we owe, not much, I suppose' could imply a realization that their grievances and regrets may not be as significant as they once thought, or it could be a sarcastic remark on the triviality of their disputes.

The repeated refrain 'Don't split your sails over me' serves as a plea for emotional detachment, indicating that the protagonist believes the relationship's issues are not worth the turmoil. The imagery of 'splitting sails' evokes a sense of directionless wandering and futile effort, reinforcing the idea that continuing to dwell on past mistakes is unproductive. The discovery of a mannequin in a plastic bin further symbolizes the artificiality and emptiness of their past interactions, suggesting that what remains is hollow and devoid of genuine emotion. Through these vivid metaphors and introspective lyrics, Pixies craft a poignant narrative about the complexities of regret and the struggle to move on from past relationships.