Building A Mystery

Sarah McLachlan's 'Building A Mystery' delves into the complexities of human nature and the facades people construct to navigate their lives. The song paints a vivid picture of a person who thrives in the night, embodying a blend of darkness and light. This character is enigmatic, adorned in 'rasta wear' and reciting 'suicide poems,' symbolizing a mix of cultural rebellion and deep-seated melancholy. The reference to a 'cross from a faith that died before Jesus came' suggests a disconnection from traditional beliefs, hinting at a search for meaning in unconventional places.

The lyrics further describe this person as living in a church, surrounded by voodoo dolls and haunted by ghosts, which could be metaphors for their inner demons and unresolved past. The imagery of wearing sandals in the snow and a smile that won't wash away highlights their contradictions and the effort to maintain a facade. The line 'Can you look out the window without your shadow getting in the way?' questions whether they can face the world without being overshadowed by their own complexities.

McLachlan's chorus, 'You're working, building a mystery, holding on and holding it in,' underscores the ongoing effort to maintain this enigmatic persona. The song suggests that this person is both beautiful and flawed, with an 'edge and charm' that is carefully curated. The repeated emphasis on 'choosing so carefully' indicates a deliberate construction of their identity, balancing vulnerability and strength. Ultimately, 'Building A Mystery' is a poignant exploration of the masks people wear and the intricate process of self-discovery and self-preservation.