All Would Envy

Shawn Colvin's song "All Would Envy" delves into the complexities of a relationship between an older man and a younger woman, exploring themes of societal expectations, materialism, and the passage of time. The lyrics paint a vivid picture of a young woman who is initially captivated by the charm and wealth of an older man. He showers her with gifts and attention, making her feel like a queen. This relationship, however, is not as perfect as it seems to the outside world. The young men who once had a chance with her are left nursing their grievances, while the older man basks in the envy of his peers.

As the song progresses, it becomes clear that the young woman's life, though filled with luxury, is not fulfilling. She lives in a grand house on a hill, but the ticking clock serves as a constant reminder that time is passing her by. She denies her boredom and insists she wouldn't change a thing, yet her actions suggest otherwise. She spends nights away from home, dancing with an old friend, seeking the romance and excitement that her current life lacks. The older man, on the other hand, is set in his ways and relies on medication to sleep, highlighting the growing disconnect between them.

The song's poignant conclusion questions the initial envy that others felt towards the couple. The repeated refrain, "Who would envy?" underscores the realization that their seemingly perfect life is fraught with dissatisfaction and unfulfilled desires. Colvin's storytelling captures the bittersweet reality that material wealth and societal approval cannot guarantee happiness. The song serves as a reminder that true contentment comes from within and that the grass is not always greener on the other side.