Strange Mercy

St. Vincent's 'Strange Mercy' is a hauntingly beautiful song that delves into themes of familial estrangement, protection, and the complexities of offering comfort in a world filled with pain. The lyrics open with a tender address to a 'little one,' suggesting a younger sibling or a child, who has been enduring hardship for a long time. The narrator acknowledges their own absence, hinting at a sense of guilt or regret for not being there. The act of waving when they see each other becomes a small but significant gesture of connection and recognition.

The song then shifts to a more specific familial context, mentioning a 'Hemingway jawline' and a father in exile. This imagery evokes a sense of inherited traits and the long-lasting impact of familial separation. The father’s exile is shrouded in mystery, adding a layer of unresolved tension and sorrow. The narrator's promise to be with the 'lost boys'—a reference to Peter Pan's group of children who never grow up—suggests a desire to protect and offer solace to those who are vulnerable and marginalized.

The chorus introduces the concept of 'strange mercy,' a paradoxical form of comfort that may not be entirely genuine but is offered out of love and necessity. The mention of a 'dirty policeman' who has caused harm adds a layer of social commentary, highlighting the injustices that the 'little one' has faced. The narrator's vow to confront this figure underscores a deep sense of protective anger. Ultimately, 'Strange Mercy' is a poignant exploration of the complexities of love, protection, and the small acts of kindness that can make a difference in a harsh world.