Broken Man

St. Vincent's song 'Broken Man' delves into the complex interplay between strength and vulnerability. The lyrics paint a picture of a protagonist who outwardly exudes power and confidence, describing themselves as a 'kingsize killer' and an 'earthquake shakin'.' These metaphors suggest a person who can command attention and influence their surroundings. However, beneath this facade lies a deep sense of brokenness and fragility, as highlighted by the repeated question, 'Like you never seen a broken man.' This juxtaposition of strength and vulnerability is a central theme in the song, reflecting the duality of human nature.

The chorus, with its insistent questioning, 'What are you looking at? Who the hell do you think I am?' challenges the listener to confront their perceptions and assumptions about the protagonist. This confrontation is not just with the external world but also an internal struggle. The lines 'You built my tower to tear it down' and 'If I stopped cracking up myself' suggest a cycle of self-destruction and rebuilding, a common theme in St. Vincent's work. The imagery of building and tearing down a tower can be seen as a metaphor for the highs and lows of personal growth and the constant battle to maintain one's identity amidst external pressures.

The plea for connection in the lines 'Lover, nail yourself right to me' and 'I need you to drive the nail' adds another layer of complexity to the song. It speaks to the human need for intimacy and support, even when one feels broken. This vulnerability is a stark contrast to the earlier declarations of power, highlighting the multifaceted nature of the protagonist's character. St. Vincent's ability to weave these themes together in a compelling narrative showcases her talent for exploring the depths of human emotion and experience.