Once Was A Time I Thought

The Mamas & The Papas' song "Once Was A Time I Thought" delves into the transformation of the narrator's understanding of love. Initially, the lyrics reflect a cynical view, where love is seen as something transactional, something that could be bought or sold. This perspective suggests a disillusionment with the idea of genuine emotional connection, perhaps influenced by past disappointments or societal norms that commodify relationships. The narrator's cautious approach to passion, described as rationing it with caution, indicates a protective mechanism against potential heartbreak.

As the song progresses, a shift occurs. The narrator describes a seemingly mundane Sunday stroll that becomes a moment of revelation. The imagery of "peanuts and pigeons and people" symbolizes the everyday distractions and interactions that initially seem to trap the narrator in a state of melancholy. However, this walk also brings about a refreshing change, dispelling the "depressing distressing salt" from the narrator's soul. This metaphor suggests a cleansing or purifying experience, leading to a newfound clarity and openness to love.

The final verses reveal the transformative power of a new relationship. With a partner by their side, the narrator feels a deep sense of satisfaction and fulfillment, challenging their previous beliefs about love. The line "Somebody must have lied to me" underscores the realization that love is not a commodity but a profound and enriching experience. This journey from cynicism to genuine connection highlights the song's central theme: the redemptive and transformative power of love.