Why Do I Love You So?

Johnny Tillotson's song 'Why Do I Love You So?' is a poignant exploration of love and loss, wrapped in the simplicity of 1960s pop music. The lyrics convey a deep sense of nostalgia and confusion faced by someone who has been left by a loved one. The repeated questioning, 'Oh my darlin', why do I love you so?' reflects the singer's struggle to understand what keeps his feelings alive despite the abandonment.

The song uses specific memories, such as the comforting gesture of stroking hair and shared moments of vulnerability, like crying over a lost pet, to illustrate the intimacy and bond that were once part of the singer's relationship. These personal moments highlight the depth of the emotional connection, making the lover's departure even more painful and incomprehensible. This juxtaposition of past happiness against current sorrow enhances the emotional weight of the song, making it relatable to anyone who has experienced a similar heartache.

Moreover, the repetition of the chorus and the haunting melody contribute to the song's reflective mood, emphasizing the cyclical nature of the singer's thoughts. The use of simple but evocative language helps listeners connect with the music on a personal level, making it a timeless piece about love, loss, and the enduring question of why one continues to love even when it brings pain.