How Could I Not?

Tom Rosenthal's song 'How Could I Not?' delves into the complexities and mysteries of love, celebrating the enigmatic nature of human relationships. The lyrics open with a reflection on the intricate workings of the beloved's mind, acknowledging that understanding it fully might be overwhelming. This sentiment is encapsulated in the lines, 'I don't know how your brain works so well / And if I did I might explode.' Here, Rosenthal suggests that the beauty of love lies in its mysteries, and attempting to decode every aspect might diminish its magic.

The chorus, 'A lifetime of trouble, but how could I not love you?' repeats the idea that despite the challenges and uncertainties that come with love, the feeling remains irresistible and essential. This line underscores the notion that love is not about perfection or complete understanding but about acceptance and devotion despite the difficulties. The repetition of this line emphasizes the unwavering commitment and the deep emotional bond that persists through life's ups and downs.

Rosenthal also touches on the human desire for certainty and the allure of mystery. The line, 'Yeah, we humans, we crave a certain certainly / But no mystery ever got old,' highlights the paradox of human nature. While we seek stability and predictability, it is the unknown and the unpredictable that keep life and love exciting and fulfilling. This duality is at the heart of the song, celebrating the balance between seeking understanding and embracing the unknown in relationships.

'How Could I Not?' is a poignant exploration of love's complexities, celebrating the beauty of its mysteries and the strength of unconditional affection. Rosenthal's gentle, introspective style invites listeners to reflect on their own experiences with love and the acceptance of its inherent uncertainties.