How Could An Angel Break My Heart

Toni Braxton's song "How Could An Angel Break My Heart" is a poignant exploration of heartbreak and betrayal. The lyrics tell the story of a woman who is devastated upon discovering that her lover has given his affection to someone else. The song opens with the protagonist hearing that her lover sang a lullaby, a deeply personal and intimate gesture, to another woman. This revelation is a crushing blow, as she believed that such tender moments were exclusively theirs. The imagery of a kiss, once a symbol of their love, now shared with another, intensifies her pain and disbelief.

The chorus of the song is a heart-wrenching plea, questioning how someone she viewed as an 'angel' could cause her such deep sorrow. The metaphor of a 'falling star' represents her shattered dreams and hopes, and she laments that perhaps her intense longing and wishes for their love inadvertently led to its demise. This introspective line suggests a sense of self-blame, adding another layer to her emotional turmoil.

As the song progresses, the protagonist continues to grapple with her feelings of loss and betrayal. She describes the other woman in idealized terms, with a face 'white as rain' and 'soft as a rose,' which only deepens her sense of inadequacy and heartbreak. The repeated refrain of the chorus underscores her desperation and confusion, as she struggles to comprehend how her once-perfect love could have ended so painfully. The song's emotional climax is marked by her soul's cry for understanding and relief from her suffering, making it a powerful anthem for anyone who has experienced the agony of a broken heart.